Recent Posts

Research Critique Hyperessay - Hole in Space

Su Hwee Lim

Wednesday, Sep 06, 2017 - 07:43:34 pm

@ Hwee's

This public communication art “Hole in space” was created in 1980 using satellite connection through a life-size video screen. The location was placed on in New York City and Los Angeles. This unexpected piece attracted large amount of people to interact with strangers also incidentally become a meeting place for people who hadn’t seen their loved ones in years.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1004&v=SyIJJr6Ldg8

People start Read more →

Categories: Research
Hi Su Hwee, I like the comparison of the same idea of how the installation works in the 1980 and 2015. We see the differences in response between people when they first interact with it. I guess that way back in the 1980s it was probably not highly possible for people to interact with each other through a screen but nowadays technology have evolved so much that communication through a screen seems much comfortable as compared to face-to-face conversation. It seems that in our generation and the generations to come I can foresee that human interaction with each other will be diminished if we do not embrace this physical interaction. I agree what you have quoted: "... we’ve come to a point where we regularly interact with people across the globe, but frequently ignore those who are right around us..." we have ignored normal conversations to embrace digital conversations. This seems very sad that we have come to this state as I see some of my friends using Whatsapp to communicate even though they are just next to each other which always puzzled me. Personally I feel that technology is closing up our world of what seems to be normal human interaction such as face-to-face while opening our world to interaction virtually where we share our life story through social media platforms or screen-based platform. I agree that the world has changed their view of interaction and rather leave the differences as it is. Overall, I love your critique and how you compared it to modern era where I can better relate to it. :D
Excellent Su Hwee... you are so right, despite the increased access to communications, it doesn't necessarily mean we are more engaged with people around us in a social context. But Hole in Space proves, as you point out, that there can be engagement despite distance in the form of online or in this case satellite communications. This is a very important statement you have made:
It shows how the video interaction would communicate emotion. 
I couldn't agree more and that is something we will be exploring throughout the course.

Research Critique: Hole in Space and Welcome to 'Electronic Cafe International'

Mirei Shirai

Wednesday, Sep 06, 2017 - 04:01:53 pm

@ Mirei's Studio

Sculpting and expressing our identities through another medium has been a human-specific phenomenon since the beginning of history. From cave paintings to portraits, and writing letters to auto-biography, we have been using a medium to imprint our subjectivity for others to see. Galloway and Rabinowitz’s “public communication sculpture” work Hole in Space was one of the first works that explored human Read more →

Categories: Research
You are completely correct when you talk about how we engage with the net, either as passive consumers or take more agency in our interactions. Do we want the Internet to become passive like television? Or do we want to take full advantage of the many-to-many characteristics of the medium. This is precisely what Kit and Sherrie were exploring in Hole in Space. Also, I was impressed with your observation that the viewers did not see themselves (virtually), but rather those on the "other side." This created in many ways a more authentic experience of the third space, in which distance was collapsed without the inclusion of your own image, more like how we see people in real life.

Research Critique: Hole in Space

Ong Zi Feng

Wednesday, Sep 06, 2017 - 11:40:51 am

@ Basics

If I imagined that I am living in 1980 where the best computer I could ever purchase(if I am even rich enough) are only running on MS-DOS operating system, a period which the first computer that runs graphical user interface only appeared 3 years later(Apple Lisa), and I heard that I could talk to someone else 4800km Read more →

Categories: Research
Wonderful essay, and you demonstrate how exciting and playful networked communications can be. You also made an astute comment about the fact that people were interacting with others in both the first space and the third space, creating a more hybrid interaction between the various dimensions of the real and the virtual. Given that this was one of the very first video chat, if not the first, it is quite astounding that this type of interaction, joining public spaces in the third space, is not more common. Despite the fact that Hole in Space was created almost forty years ago, it is still way ahead of its time.

Research Critique: Hole in Space

Hannah

Tuesday, Sep 05, 2017 - 07:28:20 pm

@ Hannah Kwah

Hole in Space:

Hole in Space is a telematic artwork where a two-way satellite linked Lincoln Center in New York and Century City in Los Angeles through two large screens where life sized images are displayed. There was no public announcement but every day the number of people interacting increases where it lasted for 3 days. Hole in Space brings people Read more →

Categories: Research
Hi Hannah, I agree with your part where there is advantage and disadvantage of virtual space. The part where you brought up countries who are in bad term could interact with each other. It also reminds me that they could understand each other from a different point of view from the virtual space. They would get hints about each other lifestyle and probably would wipe of the stereotype mindset of each other. Disadvantage also the part where you mention about physical distance. I do feel that as well it just feel different that if you are with your family physically or without. It is something that the virtual space cannot provide. Lastly I feel you got a good point on we blind ourselves with the different boundaries. We indeed set our own boundaries that limit ourselves to do certain things or react in certain ways. One example I can though of is the awkwardness that younger generations have been talking about. I feel its really something that they set on their mind that its awkward being like that or that, however if changing in another perspective is not really that awkward. Its the mindset. just sharing! I enjoyed your Critique! :)
Very good... and I found it interesting that you considered the work focused on the first and second spaces. Now that is because you don't see yourself in the image, which we normally would think of as the "third space." But if you are in a physical location where you can view the screen showing people in the second space (remote), does that combination of the physical and the virtual constitute the third space? I think so, but I also think that your interpretation is valid as well. I just wanted you to think about it. I like your ending, considering the creative possibilities when you defy geographical separation and engage with other people who are remote. That is what we are exploring in class and I am glad you pointed out how this medium lends itself to artistic experimentation.

Research Critique - A Hole in Space (1980)

Joan

Monday, Sep 04, 2017 - 01:24:54 pm

@ Joan

A Hole in Space (1980) by Kit Galloway and Sherrie Rabinowitz consists of two large projection screens, one at the Century City in Los Angeles and the other at the Lincoln Center in New York City, both screening real-time footage of people from the other city. As such technology was rather advanced at the time, most people were foreign to Read more →

Categories: Research
Excellent... and I particularly liked your comment about the genuine nature or authenticity or honesty in the interaction. It is true, today we reconstruct our online identities to suit our needs, enjoyment, and social relationships. However with Hole in Space, because as you point out it was so novel and new, people were just discovering the idea and didn't attempt to hide their true nature and reveal themselves. Plus, that is why Kit and Sherrie chose to put the piece unexpectedly, without announcement, in a public space: to provoke and illicit an honest, sincere response. It's so great that you pointed that out.

Hole in Space - Research Critique

Nicholas Makoto

Monday, Sep 04, 2017 - 12:16:05 pm

@ Grandma Joe

Viewing Hole in Space is quite fascinating. The first thing that struck me were the masses forming at the point of contact; a sort of sign that shows how people are drawn to be in contact with other people. They are especially drawn to the fact that, ordinarily, they would not be able to be in such direct contact with Read more →

Categories: Research
I particularly enjoyed this final comment:
Pushing the boundaries of technology was one thing, but to do so in a manner that touched on something quite innate for people was really, very special.
Another way of saying this is that it is more than just having access to information technology and the communications system, but it is having access to people. Creating social contact and interaction through communications media. That is precisely what Kit and Sherrie were working towards in all of their projects. Excellent that you dug deeper into other documentation of theirs concerning the Electronic Café. This was another important communications project that brought people together from all over Lost Angeles, and later the entire world. You can see how Hole in Space opened up a communications link between New York City and Los Angeles, but today, this link exists from our computers to all points around the world. And yet, are we using the communications media as creatively as Kit and Sherrie did?
Hi Makoto, I felt that some statements you made were rather thought provoking - on how people are more 'free and easy' online..and how people do not really think much about it. Hence, apart from the absence of physical space, what do you think makes us bolder and more 'free and easy' in a virtual space? Also, if you were to be commissioned a remake of Hole in Space in our current day context, which two locations will you choose? And what're the factors that you weighed in? I enjoyed reading your critique. Keep the thoughts and inputs coming! Val

Research Critique: Hole In Space

Siewhua

Sunday, Sep 03, 2017 - 10:58:50 pm

@ Siewhua 's

“Hole in Space” (1980) by Kit Galloway and Sherrie Rabinowitz resembles what we call the video chat now when implemented at that time. It went for 3 days at the walkways of Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts (New York City), and the broadway department store located in the open air Shopping Center in Century City (Los Angeles). It was a Read more →

Categories: Research
Excellent conclusion regarding how this people is an example of collective narrative. This is a great statement:
Hence, this allowed for a rich diversity of personalities, characteristics, stories to be mixed together beautifully into as one.
Doesn't this resemble our experience with social media today? Or do we just take our online interactions for granted without injecting this level of enthusiasm, emotion, and creative play? Does Hole in Space inspire our social media interactions? Does it show just how meaningful our online relationships can be, if we approach them with more creative thought. It's very good that you brought up these important issues, which we will discuss further in class.
I do agree with you that it is a interesting development of technology that now we are able to steam and see one another live. However, I would like to ask you, what do you think that will further expand our knowledge on the experiences on the "third space"? What would the new "trend" that people will engage in next?

Research Critique: Hole in Space

Val Lay

Sunday, Sep 03, 2017 - 09:33:51 pm

@ ◢ ◤

Hole in Space (1980) is a quintessential piece that highlights the possibility of a performance platform that has no geographic boundaries happening in real time.  I find the title of video, ‘mother of all video chats’  a very apt name indeed, given that it was the very first large screen teleconferencing in history.

Through its medium in telecommunication, it involves the audience Read more →

Categories: Research
Excellent research, very thorough and comprehensive, and extremely well documented. You are definitely an OSS power user!! I was particularly impressed with this statement you made:
a reason why Hole in Space was picked up by the media in a matter of days or regarded as a successful piece for expansion is the work’s ability to capture audience on an emotional level.
I agree, one of the key reasons why Hole in Space is so important historically, is because it proved beyond any doubt that there could be high level engagement and social interaction despite geographical separation. In fact, technology does bring us together, it unites us in the third space, it creatives a playful environment for interaction. And as you point out, it is less inhibited and provokes extreme responses from participants. And I like how you also pointed out that the participants are the new actors on the virtual stage.
Hi Valerie, I liked your observation on the couple flirting through Hole in Space, even in the 1980s. I think how people change their behavior through a medium is something we can observe and relate to the current Internet users. The way the couple talked could be compared to how people use online dating services nowadays, and accessibility to formation of relationships. Your additional research on recent Hole in Space also shows that people continue to have a sort of alter-ego online. I think it is interesting to further investigate why we tend to behave bold in front of the webcam, and why the barrier of etiquette diminishes through online interactions.
Hi Val, good job with the effort you put into researching about this! I agree with many points that you mentioned about how people are bolder and less restricted virtually than compared to when in reality. It was also interesting to see the difference between the two similar works but in very different time periods seem to have varying differences but how some things still stay the same. One question that I thought about was whether such instant video communication is actually bringing people closer or further away in current times? Since with such advancements, some people would tend to take advantage of such opportunities. Also, it also shows how people behave differently in reality as compared to when they're put up for the whole world to see.

“Welcome to Electronic Café International” Research Critic

Goh Cher See

Sunday, Sep 03, 2017 - 03:24:02 pm

@ CherSee

“Welcome to Electronic Cafe International” was a fascinating piece of reading, documenting the work of Kit Galloway and Sherrie Rabinowitz and their seminal work, Hole-in-Space from 1980. It discussed greatly on the effects of the artwork on the people that had interacted with it and how their behavior changed after the event.

I found the artwork by Kit Galloway and Sherrie Rabinowitz an inspiration to Read more →

Categories: Research
I too agree with you that the “third space” removes all those restrictions which is put in place by society. I feel that having able to let ourselves loose in the “third space”  allows us to feel comfortable while using social media which decreases our scepticism towards new and emerging communication technologies.
Cher See, interesting thoughts on the third space and how we can engage it and explore it for artistic purposes. And yes, from the quote you selected, there are no rules, or perhaps a new set of rule that define and propel our actions in the third space environments. What is missing from your essay is specifics: you should describe Hole in Space, how it worked, how it connected audiences in New York and Los Angeles, how people responded, specifically with emotion and excitement, and perhaps explain why they had that kind of positive experience. You touched on many larger concepts, but it is also very important to flesh out the details and describe what you saw and heard when you viewed the piece.

Yes, I definitely agree that the third space provides us a new dimension without rules and etiquette, allowing us to act our true selves. It encourages us to be fearless and more experimental in our interactions with others, as the third space only features an “extension” of ourselves. The Hole-In-Space was an installation that came as a surprise to the public, and as one of the newest forms of technology at the time. The work was approached with genuine curiosity and the social interactions made through it was perhaps the most authentic. I liked how you mentioned how the relationships between the Koreans and Blacks improved specifically from this type of interactions.

 

Today, our identity on the third space seems to have evolve quite a bit, as we hold the power to reconstruct ourselves on the net. The freedom that the Internet provides also opened doors to fake identities, malicious intentions and anonymous hacking. Do you think the change in our behaviour is influenced by the informality of the third space?

"Welcome to Electronic Café International" Research reading

BAO

Sunday, Sep 03, 2017 - 10:18:44 am

@ BAO

Welcome to Electronic Café International is a remarkable read as it truly shows communicating through the “third space” lets people feel the core of this project, warmth and closeness. Hole in Space by Kit Galloway and Sherrie Rabinowit has created a portal of spontaneously and was able to capture the essence of using the electronics for interaction bringing people from Read more →

Categories: Research
Yes! I totally agree with you that the technology used in the Hole-in-Space brought people together and it also gave them a sense belonging to the same group as they are exploring this bizarre piece of artwork together even though the other party were far away.  People were excited about the art work and drove down to "meet" their friends or family is also a prove that there was demand for such technology back then and there may be people who are skeptical on this, but there are also a big group of people who got excited and happy from it, I guess the time changed but people are still the same, there are always a group of people who will be resistant to change and there will be those who embrace them. I really like your post! keep it up!
Bao, you caught many good points in Hole in Space, including the social component when you mention community involvement, and also, the engaging nature of the work despite the geographical separation of the viewers. I would like to see more specific responses as to what was taking place in Hole in Space, and perhaps a quote from the reading that ties more to the concept of the work. And don't forget to use the blockquote when you are quoting. Otherwise good essay.
Okay! I will use the blockquote next time! Thank you!