Hidden In The City, Yet In Clear View

Standard

 

Final Project: ‘Beneath our success’ booklet

by Noraidil Sufyan & Lester Tan

test

Screen Shot 2016-04-05 at 3.38.05 pm
Screen Shot 2016-04-05 at 3.33.14 pm

Full pages available online: http://snack.to/bhp0dil9

Our project is based on the session we had at HealthServe as well as the interviews we did near Jurong East with migrant workers. We decided on creating a booklet as a documentation of these workers. We aim to enlighten the public and to remind Singaporeans of the existence of these people who are responsible behind the success of our country. 

The booklet is largely a photo montage with few words, as we want readers to develop their own feelings when flipping through the pages. We inserted  a few quotes for every worker we interviewed. Some of the names were altered to protect the identity of these workers. 


 

 

A) Write a narrative of how your idea developed. (Begin by giving some response to the 1st dance and games night)

The first night at HealthServe served as an ice-breaking session between the students and the various foreign workers present. The dance and games actually helped most of us open up to each other, leading to a smoother conversational opportunity. We found out about their dormitory lives as well as the kind of food that they had to consume. This made us wonder, just what these foreign workers experience while living and working here in Singapore. 

B) What about our meet-ups and the conversations you had created the interest in the area you ended up researching? Use your documentation photos etc.. to explain this process.

Whilst communicating with the workers, we found out that we knew very little about them aside from the fact that they are in Singapore to work and take home their monthly salary. Across the 3 trips to HealthServe, as well as our interactions with foreign workers in public areas, we got to learn a little more about their daily lives and thoughts living in the lion city. Along with these information, it prompted us to note and document these information which for the most of us, have never heard before. 

DSC_0488Showing us the living condition of their dormitories 

DSC_0505One of the social workers (far right) telling us stories of these workers

DSC_0553

Sampling of food they eat everyday

DSC_0531DSC_0532

Dinner and chit chat session with workers

C) Discuss your exchange with the foreign workers.

Having spoken to multiple foreign workers, most of them have claimed that they liked their time working here in Singapore. In fact, a few of them even went on to say that the government, transportation and people here triumphed what they face back home. It was also interesting to hear about the jobs that they are contracted to do – working at heights, in the shipyards, plantations etc – as the chances of hearing a local in that job is low. Also, it was a common point from them that the aim of coming to Singapore to work was to earn money to support themselves and their families. And perhaps the most surprising thing was just how friendly and even jovial they were through our interactions. This was definitely not what we would have expected pre-interaction.  

  1. How did you initially see the foreign workers? Did you even consider their experience before our meet-ups?

Lester’s response:

I have had the opportunity to work with foreign workers from various countries in the past before,  but without a chance to interact with them about anything other than work related issues. I only saw them as people who came to Singapore to work and earn money to take home for themselves and their families. Aside from work, I never thought that interacting with the foreign workers was possible, as the chances of chatting with a random foreign worker in public was low.

Noraidil’s response:

Before the visit to HealthServe, I admitted that I was indifferent towards foreign workers here in Singapore. While I do have some knowledge that living conditions of these people in dormitories are terrible, it was a rude awakening to me to find out the severity of this issue. I came to realisation that Singaporeans are taking the migrant workers for granted, and that we are not grateful to the things we already have. They deserved much more, after all they have done in making this country a better place for us to live in. After few visits to the Activity Centre in Tai Seng, I found out that these workers were very easy to talk to and, open-minded.

  1. Along your journey what to, and when did you change your ideas/plans in response to what you learned/experienced or observed from contact with the foreign workers?

Lester’s response:

The idea of featuring stories about the foreign workers didn’t actually come to use during any of the three meet ups at HealthServe. In fact, the idea only popped up when we were trying to capture images and interviewing the foreign workers who were hanging around Chinese Garden and Jurong East. Speaking to multiple foreign workers made us realise that we didn’t really know anything about their lives and experiences, which gave us the idea of documenting their experiences here in Singapore.

Noraidil’s response:

My initial idea was to focus on what they do in their leisure time. I wanted to gather information on how they spend their free time here and which part of Singapore they usually hang out. However after several visits to HealthServe centre as well as interacting with random foreign workers near Jurong East area, I gather that leisure time was not important to them. These migrant workers do not have much leisure time; they even have to be on standby on their off days in case of emergency. At this point, I realized it was more important to document and create awareness to Singaporeans on how foreign workers’ live their lives and their experiences here.

  1. What new knowledge did you gain from the interaction with the foreign workers and the action you took executing your project?

Lester’s response:

Upon the interactions with them, it can be said that the foreign workers are very happy to be here in Singapore. Most of them have showered praise upon the government, transportation and people, which is the complete opposite of what most Singaporeans would say. Also, the working life and conditions that Singaporeans experience cannot be compared to those of the foreign workers. 6-day work weeks doing odd jobs for long hours, and at inconvenient places are what these foreign workers do week in and week out. And yet, they hardly complain. Thus, if we were to compare our working life with theirs, we definitely have it better than them.

Noraidil’s response:

If there is one thing about these workers here that we Singaporeans are lacking, is being thankful to what we have. These foreign workers were not shy of commending Singapore’s modernized system. Particularly, the transport and security system of Singapore. They were full of praises, often comparing to the ones in their countries. I also gather that some of these workers work much longer hours than an average Singaporeans do, with measly salaries.  On the other hand, more often than not we see Singaporeans making a big fuss on the littlest things. Complains are palpable everywhere especially on social media, trains were too slow, houses are too small etc. It’s a pity that there will never be enough for Singaporeans.

  1. What did you gain or what are the strengths/weaknesses/ differences & responses to learning that does not follow the conventional path of lecture/ tutorial and studio practice: learning by creating experiences beyond the classroom? How did you feel about creating a project where there was no clear path to follow–where you had to develop a unique path?

Lester’s response:

Life experiences. Using this project as an example, the idea of any of us interacting with foreign workers would probably never have popped up in our minds pre-project. And that probably wouldn’t be possible had we remained in a classroom environment. Giving us the freedom to create a piece of work encourages us to think out of the box; to get creative to say otherwise. At times, following a path laid out for you restricts your creativity level. Hence, with the freedom to do a project on any medium, the possibilities are certainly endless.

Noraidil’s response:

I was at first, very uncomfortable and confused when I learnt that the class does not follow the conventional lecture or tutorial practice. As a student from the engineering faculty I am used to following curriculum structure. However towards the second half of the module, I began to appreciate the motives behind the boundless classroom setting. I was able to think out of the box and let my creative juices flow. There was no ‘correct’ way on how I should embark on my project and this freedom allows me to constantly explore the topic on my own with little guidance. I would certainly hope every art module to be in this manner.