Y1S2 | Experimental Interaction | Micro-Project 2 | Crowd-Sourced Art

Introduction

In Micro-Project 1, we were taught the idea of Do-It-With-Others (DIWO).

In Micro-Project 2, we applied the idea of DIWO.

As an artist myself, this is the first ever project that I have completed with others to create the final product, and the results turned out to be pretty interesting,

My group was told to create our own crowd-sourced artwork using any social media or online platforms such as Instagram, Facebook, Google Doc etc. Before starting, I did a few research to gain some inspirations. I chanced upon an artwork by Craig D. Giffen, which gained my attention. It’s called “Human Clock”.

Human Cock is actually a website named simply “Humanclock.com”, and it shows a photograph or video with the current time represented somewhere in it. The photo/video changes every minute, all 1,440 occurring minutes on Earth. Audiences from all around the world are able to submit images of the time and it will be shown on the website at that point in time.

Here are some examples which I had captured:

This crowd-sourced artwork was really something that I have not seen before. Giffen uses people from all around the world to help him keep his work of art alive. The people are not his friends, neither did he deliberately choose who he wanted to take part for in Human Clock.

Giffen’s concept inspired me, the concept of having strangers to collaborate and do the work of art with you. That was when I thought to my group- why not do something that involves audiences from all around the world instead of just our close group friends that we are familiar with?

After much discussion, we decided to use two online platforms for this micro-project.

Platform 1: Omegle

Platform 2: Instagram

Omegle is a free online chat website that allows users to socialize with others without the need to register. The service randomly pairs users in one-on-one chat sessions where they chat anonymously using the names “You” and “Stranger”.

Instagram… You already know what it is.

The title of our project is called:

What is your deepest, darkest secret?

 

1. What is the content of the work and who is creating it?

In this micro-project, we asked this question, “What is your deepest, darkest secret?” to both the people of Omegle, and the people of Instagram. And that question of “What is your deepest, darkest secret?”, was the content of the work.

In Instagram, we posted the question using the sticker function on our stories, it looked like this:

On Omegle, we multiple chat boxes and started asking people the question straightaway individually (Images would be shown later for the response section).

So, who is creating this work? it would be the people of Omegle and Instagram, together with us. We would be asking the questions to them, and they would be replying to us, which is a DIWO approach. The purpose of using two different platforms, was for us to see the difference in responses garnered from both Omegle and Instagram. Omegle would be from a totally random stranger, and Instagram would only be from our own friends which we are all familiar with.

 

2. Where does this work take place?

Like what I had mentioned above, this work took place online on social media platforms, which is Omegle and Instagram in this case. We gave absolute freedom to what they wanted to respond. We did not set any constraints, restrictions or rules. We simply asked, “What is your deepest, darkest secret?”

We foresee the outcome of the responses from the two platforms to be vastly different, and it did. However, there was a major twist to the result that we thought it would be. Before you see the screen captures that we took from Omegle and Instagram, try yourself to predict what kind of replies you would expect from the crowd.

Do you have your predicted answers in mind now?

Here are the replies we reaped from Omegle:

 

Next, these are the replies we gathered from Instagram:

Take a moment to see and re-read the responses from above again. Did you expect these replies from the crowd? Did it match your predicted answers? Or did you expect something else? Let’s get back to that later on.

As you can see, the responses from Instagram were tame, while the responses from Omegle are the exact opposite, which were much more wild.

Responses from Omegle include:

  • Telling us their deepest darkest secrets
  • Asking us back the question
  • Asked if we had similar secrets

Responses from Instagram include:

  • Nonsensical phrases
  • Inside jokes
  • Not answering at all

 

3. How does this work involve social interaction?

The exchange of information we had on these two social media online platforms were the social interactions involved.

Going back to what I was mentioning earlier, the responses we gathered from both online platforms were what I had expected. However, the major twist was that the responses didn’t match the group that I had expected it to be- I expected the responses from Instagram to be wild and truthful, while the responses on Omegle to be nonsensical and thrashy. But it was the total opposite!

I thought that only the closest friends would open up to us as were had known each other for so long, and that the trust is already there. As for strangers wise, they wouldn’t dare to share much as we had zero interactions before.

After much thought process, I came up with this hypothesis:

The degree of how open one can get, depends on the extent the person is hiding behind the screen.

What I felt was that strangers had nothing to lose. Since we don’t even know them in person and we couldn’t possibly meet each other in life, they were not scared of being judged. Hence, they were more willing to open up to us.

However, those on Instagram are our close friends, people that we know. Anything that they reveal might cause uneasiness and awkwardness between us in the future. It’s in human nature for one to naturally judge a person when he or she reveals something that you wouldn’t expect he or she to do. Our friends would have to be accountable and responsible for the things they reveal, which eventually ends up for them not willing/wanting to reveal their deepest darkest secrets.

 

4. How is your crowd-sourced project different from one that is created by a single artist/creator?

The main difference between our crowd-sourced project from one that is created by a single artist/creator, would be the fact that there was a big social interaction bring involved, rather than just a one-on-one interaction.

Without multiple responses, this work of art that my group has created wouldn’t have been possible. We wouldn’t be able to study the responses of different people through one-on-one interaction, and I definitely wouldn’t be able to come up with the hypothesis I stated earlier because there wouldn’t have been many pieces of evidence.

However, one might ask if the crowd would be able to change our intention of the whole project. The answer is yes they can, and they did. The images that we have shown on top are the ones that we successfully managed to have a conversation with them. For those that quit the chat after we asked the question, we didn’t manage to collect any responses from those people. These are the ones that alter our aim of this project, as they weren’t keen to reply and hence, we consider them as not participating in the project.

This was the reason why we had to create chatrooms after chatrooms to garner more answers and responses, rather than limit the number of interactions. The more interactions we managed to achieve, the more accurate the results we get, which makes this Work of Art more realistic and genuine.

In conclusion, this micro-project was an eye-opening experience for me as I had never done any forms of Art with a crowd. What was more interesting was the fact that my group and I didn’t expect the end result to be the total opposite of what we predicted it to be initially.

Y1S2 | Experimental Interaction | Micro-Project 1 | Creating the Third Space

1.  Why did you choose this space or object to photograph?

Whether or not you had taken this lift before, somehow or rather you would have walked past this space before. Not many people use this lift. The minority who chose to use this lift has a certain personality only a few could understand, and those few are the ones who use this lift. I am one of them. There are so many reasons on why one shouldn’t use this lift: it is for the handicapped, there are two proper lifts at the lobby, it is slow like- and the list goes on. But, we still use it. People whom I’ve met while taking this lift together seemed to be able to click with me instantly, probably because of the similar mindsets we possess and our indifferent attitude towards others, which is the certain personality I was referring to earlier. What mindsets you might ask? If you know, you know. Hope to see you at that space sometime soon, only if you belong there.

 

2. What are some of the characteristics of this alternative virtual space you had created collectively?

A visual without explanation could have endless meanings. Scrolling through #1010adm, there was nothing new or interesting if we were just talking about visual wise- how creative could one get when we are bounded by only the school compound? Classrooms, library, study tables, or a cozy corner somewhere in the school.

However, if the Artist decides to explain the meaning of the visual he or she created, we as the audience could then see the true colours behind the Work of Art. In this case, the Instagram captions are the ones that make the difference. After reading a few posts, I came to the conclusion that there is a form of solidarity and coherence amongst us ADMers. We might not express as much when we are interacting in real life, but through this virtual space, the sense of unity and unanimity brought all of us to our consensus as one. Something that one could never escape in ADM- working day and night, rushing and completing the projects given to us.

Its wild though- us in this generation, being able to communicate better only through the virtual life. Good or bad, at least there is a platform where we can finally form a virtual space to share thoughts where everyone appreciates each other.

 

3. Under what circumstance will this alternative virtual space change?

I felt that this alternative visual space has a lot of similarities to “Cut Piece” by Yoko Ono, the Work of Art that we were tasked to discuss during our first lesson in Experimental Interaction. This alternative virtual space acts like Yoko Ono’s clothes. We, the audience, are the one executing physical actions, which transforms the Work of Art. One might argue that Yoko Ono also played a part as well, which was her ignorance towards this whole process. By not reacting or doing anything, it allowed the audience to transform the Work of Art freely.

Similar but not so similar to this project of “Creating The Third Space”, we (my classmates & I), are the ones who changed the virtual space inside Instagram by taking photos and posting it up with our own personal captions. The only difference is that Instagram isn’t real- it doesn’t have feelings, and it would not be able to make any decisions as it is just an Artificial Intelligence (AI), if we were to compare it with Yoko Ono. Therefore, I can conclude that we are the only ones that played a part in changing this alternative virtual space inside Instagram. Without us, the virtual space stays the same, cold and empty.

 

4. How does this project relate to what we discussed in the lecture regarding co-creation, the concept of Do-It-Yourself (DIY), Do-It-With-Others (DIWO)?

My personal definition for the three main concepts comprising of co-creation, Do-It-Yourself (DIY), and Do-It-With-Others (DIWO), are:

Co-creation: Creating something yourself, together with the aid from others.

DIY: Creating something all by yourself.

DIWO: Creating something together with others.

Here is how I view this whole project of “Creating The Third Space” with regards to the three main concepts:

The notion of us going around ADM to photograph a space or object is DIY, because everything is done personally. From sourcing the location, to taking a photo, and then uploading it on Instagram are all done by our own physical actions.

The co-creation then starts here, when we write our own captions with #1010adm hashtag.

Lastly, the DIWO is the part when all of our photos are directed into one virtual space as one after tagging #1010adm in our own photos. In this virtual space, all forms of interactions happen- all of us are free to comment and like on each other’s photos.

This is when the virtual space starts to alter and mold itself according to all our actions, creating a new alternative virtual space there and then.