We had to present our 4 quote composition designs to the class.
Gattaca
“You want to know how I did it? This is how I did it, Anton: I never saved anything for the swim back.”
The Help
“Every morning, until you dead in the ground, you gone have to make this decision. You gone have to ask yourself, “Am I gone believe what them fools say about me today?””
Critique:
– The sunburst is quite distracting. Maybe you can lighten it.
– The girl is very small and the owl head can barely be seen – the owl head blends into the background due to both being very dark. Make the owl-girl bigger so that it can be seen.
– Posture of girl comes off as arrogant.
– Liked the use of the tarrot card motif.
Further Edits:
Looking at the comment about the little girl having an arrogant posture instead of a subservient or neutral posture, I went to search the internet to replace it. I scrolled and scrolled till I finally found an image which I think would suit. It is of a girl crying(below). I wanted to use the picture, however, the size is small and resolution is terrible. It became very blurry after I tried to expand the size. I had to take into account that it looks very pixelated on my computer screen already.
With regards to the comment of the owl-girl being too small, I enlarged her figure so that she has more presence in the composition now.
Next, I tried to improve on 2 points. Even though the owl-girl is bigger and more visible now(so she does not blend so much into the background), I wanted to try to further make her more visible. Combining with the comment that the sunburst ray like effect seemed quite distracting and out-of-the-blue, I wanted to make the idea of why I chose to use this effect more obvious. Firstly, I originally intended it to correspond to the phrase “every morning” in the quote, to represent the sun. Anyway, I tried to make a circular white space around the owl-girl. Firstly, it makes the owl-girl more visible as she is in a white background now so she does not blend into the surroundings, and secondly, to make the idea of morning-sun more obvious by literally having a circular sun with light rays shining out.
Not quite sure how I felt about the ray lines continuing to extend to the center(despite faintly), hence I tried to clean it up some more in the next one.
I had second thoughts about the size of the circle, I then made the circle diameter bigger to surround the owl-girl fully ever so slightly.
Likewise, I’m still note sure about the faint lines leading to the center point as it feels slightly distracting. So I tried erasing it off.
It feels too abrupt though, in that the rays of light suddenly disappear into this massive white circle. I tried to decrease that “visual shock” by leaving an outer rim of faded lines before fully erasing it away.
Forrest Gump
“My mama always said, ‘Life was like a box of chocolates. You never know what you’re gonna get.’”
Critique:
– The chocolate idea can be more apparent. There is no show of what the choc is or where. Although (everyone) not sure how to either.
Further Edits:
I went to google on images of chocolates. These are some results of what I got.
Looking at these images, I’m still not quite sure how to best doing it without it being too literal. Some ideas I can think of is to use the the texture of the gold foil wrapper of Ferraro Rocher chocolates in the black circle.
However, I don’t really like it as it is far too much texture present – especially with the 8 boxes and their motifs, it complicates the composition too much in my opinion. I still prefer my composition I presented for class(a simple black circle to tie the composition together). I think it is so hard to incorporate chocolates as they literally come in every shape, pattern and size. There is not much of a recognizable form except for the block-y kind(last chocolate picture), which is very cliche in my opinion.
Inside Out
“Take her to the moon for me okay?”
Critique:
– The ray of light highlights the imagery – which is nice.
– Like how Bing Bong is sad yet the overall composition is very happy and fun – the contrast.
– Bing Bong can be more obvious.
– Bing Bong can be bigger and sadder in posture.
Overall critique:
– Like the overall use of symbolism