Toa Payoh zine process

You can check out part 1 here: https://oss.adm.ntu.edu.sg/yuol0001/toa-payoh-site-research/

Part 1.2 Ideation: https://oss.adm.ntu.edu.sg/yuol0001/toa-payoh-ideation/

Part 3 Final: https://oss.adm.ntu.edu.sg/yuol0001/a-journey-in-toa-payoh-final/


In my earlier ideation and drafts, I only used two colours- black and white to emphasise the graphic nature of my designs. After the first test print, I felt that the dichotomy of colours was not interesting enough to highlight key events of each spread. Thus I added bright red into each page. I kept it to a minimal to show consistency and harmonise the pages in its entirety.

 

After consulting with mimi, her main advice to me was to create a logo to represent toa payoh, allowing me to introduce various locations to my readers. My friends suggested I add the timestamp onto each location, to emphasise the feeling of a travelogue.  I feel these two additions really helped to stitch the zine together and bring the readers on a journey together.

 

I believed that since the zine was a physical copy of our work, it should be not soley a visual experience, but also a sensory one. Tying in with the theme that Toa payoh is a town trapped between modernity and its past, I tried to evoke Toa payoh’s sense of tired identity into my zine. I tried to experiment and bring this out by incorporating 3d into the zine.

I attempted at embossing, creating a 3d bevel effect that will heighten and further highlight aspects of the zine.

To do so, I printed an additional cover of the zine.

I traced the shape of TOA PAYOH using my tablet as a lightbox and used an art knife to trace over the contours. I later used a pencil to draw over the contours, creating grooves and imprints.

Only the T is embossed at this moment, as you can tell from the difference in reflectability between the alphabets.

I was worried that the texture is not that obvious and will be overlooked due to its subtle nature (and also because it cant be seen on camera), but my classmates all noticed and commented on how interesting it was.

I later glued the cover onto the zine.

Besides embossing, I sought to create additional texture through wrinkling the pages of the zine to create a tired, worn out look and feel.

wrinkle created by stacking uneven layers of glue

grainy, aged and dirty texture created by rubbing dirt over glue +further crumpling paper after paper has dried.

feathery texture created by applying glue and water over “muddy”, taking off layers of paper

The edges of each page were also intentionally made wet and crumpled, causing the edges to be uneven and causing the zine to be unable to close.

These physical imperfections meant to depict how the zine has been passed through many hands and experienced many changes and effects of time. Its wear and tear are reflections of how Toa payoh has been over the years, its previous glory slowly eroding away, becoming worn out and tired.


Failure in attempt.sad

I did research and attempted this type of gilded embossing, but the embossing turned out to be rather unclean and could not tear away from my printed paper.

i learnt that the way to do a gilded emboss is when the majority of the paper to be embossed on is not oinked upon. In the case that it is inked up like mine, the gold leaf will stick to every surface with ink and will not achieve desired effect.

Toa payoh 1.2 ideation

This is a continuation of part 1 of my zine journey.

You can check out part 1 here: https://oss.adm.ntu.edu.sg/yuol0001/toa-payoh-site-research/

Part 2 process: https://oss.adm.ntu.edu.sg/yuol0001/398-2/

Part 3 Final: https://oss.adm.ntu.edu.sg/yuol0001/a-journey-in-toa-payoh-final/

 

one unique comment i received was:

my work and style resembled chinese propaganda

 

 

 

 

 

 

This got me thinking. Since Toa payoh was a mostly Chinese kampung, its roots were very ethnic Chinese. Many of the cultural heritages are also ethnic Chinese, most prominently the medical association, which specializes in Traditional Chinese Medicine. Thus, I came to the conclusion that the brushstroke, Chinese propaganda style is a good fit for this project.

This led me to think more about toa payoh’s personal relationship with the past. I visited Toa Payoh again and also went to heritage rich areas like Joo Chiat and Emerald hill.

All of these places have heritage signboards and avertise heritage tours.However, in comparison, Toa payoh did not have proper maintenance on the heritage sites. They just looked dreary and dead, seemingly without a link to the modern interest.

I felt that there was a lack of effort to relate and catch up to the modern world. This change in perspective compared to my last experience when i went there made me think

It seemed as if Toa payoh had become complacent in its search for regional identity, choosing to rest its laurels on its past glory and not choosing to make a big improvement about itself. As it is evidently unable to catch up yo progress, it seemed to have grumpily consoled itself wth its own heritage, creating a sleep atmosphere of a suburb stuck in the days of the “glorious past”.

Instead of creating a golden place of heritage and remembrance of the past like Joo Chiat, Toa Payoh is essentially creating a gilded state of antiquity. Inauthentic but out of necessity as it is unable to catch up to progress, and can only work with what it has– which is its heritage.

This is not wisdom, it is the feeble attempt to stroke one’s pride to cover up for current real inadequacies. It is an attempt to create some sort of heritage identity to stay relevant. It has taken out pages from the cultural preservation of joo chiat, but altogether lacks integrity or innovation.

Narrowing down from the original concept of a struggle for identity; unable to choose between the new and the old, I decide that i will introduce the background of struggle. I choose to create a zine resembling a cultural heritage tour, looking at the old parts of Toa Payoh from a modern perspective. It will be like a personal lament and sighing of Toa Payoh’s current state